After the waiters watch a young man and woman pass on the street, the young waiter serves the old customer another brandy and voices his impatience to the old waiter, complaining that the old man is keeping him from his warm bed and the comfort of his wife.
Major Themes In his short fiction Hemingway depicted a disillusioning environment in which his protagonists address the precariousness of existence, the evanescence of happiness, and the universality of suffering.
Much of the critical commentary on the short story focuses on a series of unattributed lines of dialogue. Critics have noted a series of contrasts in the story: A few commentators have viewed the three main characters in the story as an implied progression from youth through middle age to old age.
In fact, some of the dialogue seemed to be uttered by the wrong character. John Hagopian rejected these theories, maintaining that the confusion stemmed from a typographical error and urged a revision of the story. When the old man gestures for another brandy, the young waiter tells him that it is closing time.
He compares himself to the man, saying he understands the need for a clean, well-lighted place to be at night. Instead, he theorized that Hemingway utilized anti-metronomic dialogue—allowing a character to speak consecutive lines of dialogue in a few places. Hemingway rarely identified the speaker of each line of dialogue, and confusion ensued about which character was speaking each line.
At first, commentators speculated that there was a mistake in the text: After the old man pays his bill and leaves, the old waiter chides the young waiter for his lack of patience and empathy for the old man. This could explain the discrepancy and allow the dialogue to be logical and idiosyncratic.
Joseph Gabriel contended that the dialogue was metronomic and that the resulting confusion was viewed as an integral aspect of the story. The place is empty except for a regular customer, a deaf old man drinking alone at one of the tables. In fact, many believe that the major thematic concern of the story is the conflict between generations.
This is illustrated by the contrast between the two major characters: Realizing that the old man is drunk, one of the waiters informs the other that the customer attempted suicide the week before. Through these stylistic techniques Hemingway renders a complex series of interactions between an old waiter and his young colleague as the two men reflect on the ephemeral nature of happiness and the inevitability of death.
InOtto Reinert challenged the prevailing theory that Hemingway employed metronomic dialogue and that each indented line implied a new speaker.A Clean, Well-Lighted Place Themes Dissatisfaction Unhappiness, discontent, or just plain everyday life – call it what you will, dissatisfaction is a pretty universal theme in the works of Mr.
Ernest Hemingway. - A Clean Well-Lighted Place A Clean, Well-Lighted Place by Ernest Hemingway looks at age from the viewpoint of an inexperienced and experienced individual, with the aid of an old man to emphasize the difference between the two.
Here we've compiled a list matching the top essays in our database against "clean well lighted place es essays". The Theme Of The Generation Gap In The Story A Clean, Well-lighted Place Essay Words: This problem is clearly revealed in the story "A clean, well-lighted place" written by Ernest Hemingway.
The message of the story is. A Clean, Well-Lighted Place Essay Words | 6 Pages “ A Clean, Well-Lighted Place” by Ernest Hemingway is a simplistic short story in which he narrates a scene in a Cafe, where the main characters are two waiters and an old man. A Clean Well Lighted Place: Theme Analysis, Free Study Guides and book notes including comprehensive chapter analysis, complete summary analysis, author biography information, character profiles, theme analysis, metaphor analysis, and top ten quotes on classic literature.
Discussion of themes and motifs in Ernest Hemingway's A Clean, Well-Lighted Place. eNotes critical analyses help you gain a deeper understanding of A Clean, Well-Lighted Place so you can excel on.Download